Next Generation DVD Formats

Optical Storage Brochure
286k, 6pg.

Product line up:
HD DVD  | Blu-ray

At present there are two High Definition DVD formats, Blue-ray (BD) and HD DVD. The two formats will allow you to watch High-Definition movies at home with the future potential of recording HD on a disc. The basic technology that will make all this happen use blue-violet lasers that increase disc capacity, allowing one disc to hold hours of HDTV quality video. Although the two formats where primarily designed to be a “consumer high-definition video format”, their very high storage capacities and high-speed data transfer rates also make these competing technologies suitable for data storage libraries and ultimately other applications.

Blu-ray Disc (BD) was developed by the “Blu-ray Disc Founders” group, which include Hitachi, LG, Matsushita, Pioneer, Philips, Samsung, Sharp, Sony, Dell, Hewlett-Packard and Thomson. The competing format, HD DVD, is backed by Toshiba and NEC. Blu-ray Disc was designed with an emphasis on capacity and HD DVD targets on compatibility. Blu-ray media can hold about 50GB on a two-layer disc compared with HD DVD's 30GB (by comparison, today’s two-layer DVD holds less than 9.4GB) but as of this writing, a single-sided triple-layer 45GB HD DVD was being proposed by the HD-DVD backers.

An HD DVD disc is physically closer to today's DVDs, making it easier to manufacture discs in existing factories and to make drives that can also read and write today's DVD and CD formats. On the other hand, Blu-ray Disc is a totally new optical storage medium requiring some retooling and or construction of new disc manufacturing and replication lines. Blu-ray Disc also requires an additional protective hard-coat applied on the data layer side to shield the media from accidental abrasions, dust, and fingerprint marks. Of significant importance, Blu-ray Disc will also be compatible with current CD and DVD technologies. Both formats will offer excellent video quality.

The DVD Forum has officially endorsed HD DVD, though not unanimously. All of the major Blu-ray companies belong to the DVD Forum and many of them have no current plans to back HD DVD. Does this mean a format war? A war would weaken consumer enthusiasm and slow market acceptance. And the war will be about more than just home video. Today's DVDs are a medium for computer software distribution, retail videos, and PC backups. Blue-violet light laser DVDs will have to do all these things as well. Who will win? Who has the best format? Both are very difficult questions to answer.

Blue-ray vs. HD DVD (ROM Versions)

Blue-ray HD-DVD
Slightly Higher Capacity -25GB Slightly Lower Capacity -15GB
Blu-ray Forum Support DVD Forum Support Microsoft Intel

  High Manufacturing Cost

– New Manufacturing Lines
 – Hard Coat Required

Low Cost Conversion
Existing DVD manufacturing used for production

20th Century Fox MGM Columbia Pictures
  Disney
Hollywood Pictures
Touchstone Pictures   Screen Gem Pictures
Tristar Pictures Sony Pictures Paramount
 
Warner Home Video

Universal Pictures  New Line Cinema  HBO Viacom Paramount Warner Home Video

 

Parameters Blu-ray Disc HD DVD

Capacity per layer (GB)

25

15

Theoretical Max number of layers

4 4

Max number of sides

2 2

Substrate + cover layer (mm)

1.1 + 0.1

0.6 + 0.6

Laser wavelength (nm)

405

405

Numerical aperture

0.85

0.65

Cartridge

No No

Tilt control needed

No Yes

Hard coating needed

Yes

No

Complexity to read DVD

More complex

None

Maximum Data Rate (Mbps)

36.55 (1X)

36.55 (1X)

Maximum Recording Time (HDTV)

Single-Layer

2 hours 2 hours

Dual-Layer

4 hours 4 hours

What is High Definition Digital Versatile Disc (HD DVD)?

High Definition Digital Versatile Disc, or HD DVD, though initially called AOD for Advanced Optical Disc, is an optical disc that uses state-of-the-art blue-violet laser technology to enable extremely large-capacity recordings and high speed data transfer rates. Backed jointly by Toshiba/NEC, amongst 60 other manufacturers, these companies proposed and developed the basic format specifications. Although HD DVD was primarily designed to be a "consumer high-definition video recording format", its very high storage capacities and high-speed data transfer rates also make HD DVD suitable for storage libraries and ultimately other applications.

An HD-DVD disc has the same physical size as a DVD (12cm) but has higher data and track densities that give it between roughly three to six times the storage capacity of a standard 4.7GB DVD-R. This feat is made possible using a 405 nm (405 billionth of a meter) blue-violet laser, actually violet-purple, (see figure 1) and an optical pickup head with a 0.65 numerical aperture (NA) lens. Because a blue-violet light laser has a shorter wavelength (405 nm) than the red light (650 nm) used in CD and DVD systems, it allows the laser beam to make a smaller spot on the disc surface. With each bit of data taking up less space on the disc, more data can be stored on a 4.7-inch disc.

Why the need for so much capacity?

High-definition video (720p or 1080i) requires five times the recording capacity of standard definition video (480i). The actual HDTV transmission is based on a 19.4 Mbps (Mega bits per second) digital data stream but the maximum data transfer for DVD is about 10 Mbps. Thus, there’s simply not enough bandwidth to put an HDTV program on a recordable DVD format. To achieve the density necessary to put this amount of data on a single-sided 12 cm optical disc, the size of the spots burned into the disc need to be smaller. In addition, the high-definition video will need to undergo compression to be able to store this high-definition picture.

Video and Audio Codecs

The HD-DVD format employs MPEG-2, Video Codec 9 (VC-1 based on the Windows Media 9 format), or H.264/MPEG-4 AVC video compression techniques in order to lower the data rate (i.e., use less digital data) of the high-definition video. The excellent efficiency of the latest MPEG-4 AVC and VC-1 codec allow image data to be compressed to about one-third the size achieved by MPEG-2 and replay of high quality digital images.

But regardless of the codec utilized, the idea is to compress enough to decrease the bit rate to data capacity levels while trying to preserve the high-definition picture quality to a reasonable standard. This allows the high-definition signal to be recorded without excessive compression, preserving the detail of the original high-definition picture.

The audio formats for HD DVD extend beyond the current DVD specifications to include every type of audio codec available. Though, at this writing, the more robust DTS Digital Surround had been selected as the audio technology of choice for the High Definition Digital Versatile Disc (HD DVD).

What are the HD DVD Disc Capacities?

HD-DVD has a single-sided single-layer 15GB, a single-sided dual-layer 30GB, a single-sided triple-layer 45GB, and a 20GB (32GB under development) single-layer rewritable capacity compared to current DVDs which can hold between 4.7GB and 9.4GB of data (see Figure 2).


As of this writing, the HD DVD backers had proposed a "Hybrid" (read only) double-sided dual-layer structure disc (see figure below) containing an 8.5GB capacity standard-definition and a 30GB capacity high-definition version.

Compatibility

HD DVD maintains backward compatibility with current DVD discs since it adopts the same bonded disc structure as current red-laser DVD systems now in use, including the same thickness of the surface layer and the same process for replication. In fact, the surface layer of an HD-DVD disc is 0.6 mm thick, the same as that of a standard DVD.

HD DVD Discs will not be playable in current DVD players however existing DVD media is playable on HD DVD Disc drives that have been specifically manufactured to have backwards compatibility with DVDs.

DVD/HD DVD Format Comparison

Parameters DVD HD-DVD
Capacity per layer (GB)

4.7

15

Max number of layers 2 2
Max number of sides 2 2
Substrate + cover layer (mm) 0.6 + 0.6 0.6 + 0.6
Laser wavelength (nm) 650 405
Numerical aperture 0.60 0.65
Cartridge No No
Tilt control needed No Yes
Hard coating needed No No
Complexity to read DVD - None
Maximum Data Rate (Mbps) 11.08 (1X) 36.55 (1X)
Maximum Recording Time (HDTV) Single-Layer - 2 hours
Dual-Layer - 4 hours

Maxell, a technology and marketing leader, is a full-line manufacturer of digital media products for consumer, professional, and data storage applications.  Maxell, a recognized brand leader for over 30 years, markets a comprehensive line of digital tape and disc-based recording media products for consumer audio, video, camcorder and data storage applications.  The company also manufactures and markets a wide range of consumer battery products, as well as a full line of care and maintenance accessories, headphones and hands-free headsets.

products | dealers | support | what's new | home